Friday, May 18th 2012
 

Latest Comments

RSS

More Area News

Powers wins $356K in settlement with village

Print
Written by Amy Mayhew
Wednesday, December 28 2011

HOLLY, Michigan – After more than a year of ongoing litigation, the village of Holly can officially put the matter of Marsha Powers versus the village of Holly behind it.

Powers filed a lawsuit with the Genesee County Circuit Court against the village of Holly on Sept. 10, 2010. Holly Village Council members fired Powers without cause three days earlier after she turned down council’s offer to take an early retirement with full benefits in exchange for her giving the village of Holly a release from any legal claims she may have had.

In addition to claiming wrongful termination in her lawsuit, Powers' complaint pertained to a Whistleblower Protection Act Violation, specifically section 15.362 that discusses, “Discharge threats or discrimination against employee for reporting violations of the law.”


While a Final Order of Judgment was filed on Dec. 12, Village Manager Jerry Walker was unable to discuss the exact amount of the settlement until the village officially received the Settlement Agreement and Release of All Claims this week, thus becoming subject to the Freedom of Information Act.

In the agreement, the village of Holly and its insurer agreed to pay Powers $356,500. Additionally, the village of Holly will provide 65 percent of the health care premium for a single subscriber under the retiree health care plan beginning no later than Jan. 1, 2012 through the end of the calendar year in which Powers attains the age of 65.

On Dec. 15, Village Council members adjusted the budget and eliminated two village staffing positions for a total budget savings of $111,871. Additionally, council allocated $19,629 from the village’s fund balance for a total of $131,500.  The village’s insurance carrier picked up the remaining $225,000 in the settlement.


"Certainly as a village, we're happy to have this litigation completed," Walker said. "Members of the council took all the necessary steps in resolving the issue in the very best interest of the village."


Comments  

 
+20 #1 Ryan Bladzik Wednesday, December 28 2011 5:08pm
Well, that answers that. I'd still like to know what the "whistleblower" claim was all about...
Report to administrator
 
 
+9 #2 Janet Leslie Wednesday, December 28 2011 6:07pm
If I were a voter/taxpayer in the village of Holly, I would certainly want to know who made the colossal misstep that cost the village so much money. Even if they are not on the current council, or are but don't plan to run again, I think the voters have a right to know.
Report to administrator
 
 
+4 #3 Janet Leslie Wednesday, December 28 2011 6:33pm
However, after reading the attached settlement agreement, I see that no explanation will be forthcoming. Two people lost their jobs over this, and none of us will ever know why.
Report to administrator
 
 
-19 #4 vhogan Wednesday, December 28 2011 7:41pm
This is a lot of money and I, too, am sorry that two people lost their jobs. However, I have known Marsha for many many years. She has always been fair and honest with me and my former staff, and I have to think there is much more to this. We may never know all of the facts of this case, but I don't think it's fair to throw her under the bus.
Report to administrator
 
 
+12 #5 Lee Wednesday, December 28 2011 8:24pm
Oh, my gosh!! What next, council members??? And are we not entitled to know the whole story on this?? Let's get back on track with our citizens, please!!
Report to administrator
 
 
+2 #6 Janet Leslie Wednesday, December 28 2011 8:28pm
Having written a column in 2008 warning against allowing Marsha Powers to assume the responsibilities of village manager ("It takes a village manager," The Holly Community Voice), and having spoken to council members on many occasions expressing my doubts about her suitability for the job, I myself wouldn't say I'm throwing her under the bus.

What surprises me now is that there was apparently some validity to her "whistle blower" claim. I just can't imagine who on that council would have made the heinous mistake of threatening to fire her over some transgression that she reported. Frankly, there were too many other reasons to fire her to stoop to such nonsense.
Report to administrator
 
 
+6 #7 Lee Wednesday, December 28 2011 8:35pm
Well, Janet, I just finished reading the settlement, and I agree: we are never going to know the "whistleblower" event..kinda concerns me, doesn't it? Like a criminal still on the loose?? And why are we paying 65% of her insurance for the next umpteen years?? That's a new one to me!!
Report to administrator
 
 
+10 #8 Joe Thursday, December 29 2011 12:10am
This buffoonery has to stop.

It's pretty hard to accept the statement "Members of the council took all the necessary steps in resolving the issue in the very best interest of the village" when it's made pertaining to a legal settlement for a wrongful termination.

I'd like to see the legacy council members from the lawsuit resign or be replaced at the next electoral opportunity.
Report to administrator
 
 
-15 #9 Sophia Thursday, December 29 2011 10:08am
will the employees that were laid off be called back after one year or was this an excuse for making a permanent cut?
I would like to hear Marsha's side of the story.
Report to administrator
 
 
+4 #10 Toddski Thursday, December 29 2011 10:30am
Joe...You took the words right out of my mouth. It's hard to believe that any council person who voted for the water fiasco and now the Powers debacle can still be sitting on the council..but they are!
Report to administrator
 
 
+2 #11 SHEM001 Friday, December 30 2011 9:37am
This just makes me incredibly sad.To think what improvements and updates to the village this amount of money could have made.I agree with Ryan,Janet,and Joe also.
Report to administrator
 
 
+6 #12 TheDuke Saturday, December 31 2011 8:48am
Amy, thanks for the details that you were able to get for us. Imagine if Holly did not have an on line newspaper, all of this could have been swept under the rug and no one outside of a very few would have known about the huge settlement. And the people would not have an opportunity to speak their minds on this issue. The next time that I hear someone saying that Holly does not have a newspaper, I will point them to this article and prove them wrong.

How many years must we subsidize her health care? Also, is there any way to get the original complaint/lawsuit filing that would tell us taxpayers who are footing the bill here what the original whistle-blowing was all about? I have only seen speculation.
Report to administrator
 
 
-1 #13 Janet Leslie Saturday, December 31 2011 11:41am
I would like to second the Duke's comment and thank you, Amy, for keeping the community informed. I don't think many small communities have this level of reporting, and make no mistake, this is part of the formula that is leading to a greater prosperity for our area. One must be informed in order to act appropriately, and appropriate action leads to progress. May you have a very happy and prosperous new year!
Report to administrator
 

To comment on this article, please register for an account or log-in if you already have an account.

 



Front Page | Community | Sports and Outdoors | Opinion | Education | Holly Express | Site Map
©2012 The Holly Express.
Send feedback to Editor@theHollyExpress.com.
All rights reserved. This material may not be broadcast, published, rewritten or redistributed without prior written permission.